On paper, neotraditional neighborhoods look like heaven: a utopian mix of owners and renters, old and young, living together around a town square. They walk or bike to fetch milk or videos, or they chat with neighbors from sidewalks and front porches.
Children play in nearby parks rather than high-fenced back yards, and cars drive slower on narrowed streets and pull into garages behind the houses, linked by alleys.
But actually building these kinds of communities -- the style dates to the 1940s, in the years before subdivisions -- hasn't been easy. Until recently, they have remained a paper ideal in Austin, which in 1997 developed an ordinance to encourage such developments east of Interstate 35.
"Why try something new when what's already being built is selling like gangbusters?" asked the city's special projects director, Tracy Watson, explaining why the ordinance he wrote garnered praise and awards but few takers.
Slowly, however, the tide may be turning. On Nov. 14, a unanimous city planning commission enthusiastically approved the first project to ask for traditional neighborhood zoning. Brandt's Crossing, a community of apartments, town homes and houses arranged around shops, parks and a church, is planned for 130 acres along Slaughter Lane, just east of the interstate in far South Austin.
A similar project, planned along Dessau Road near the Jourdan-Bachman Pioneer Farm, will file its official plans for the site within a few weeks, said one of its partners, Terry Mitchell of Milburn Homes. The City Council approved $5 million in incentives for the development in April.
Both neighborhoods have been planned for more than a year, and both are months away from construction.
Part of the delay is due to the difficulty of getting builders who normally specialize in commercial property, apartments or single-family homes to work together and share the costs of public spaces, such as parks, Mitchell said.
Following the ordinance means upfront costs are higher, to pay for such extras as the town square, alleys and trees to line the streets. Brandt's Crossing's developer estimates that his community will cost about $9 million more to build than a same-size subdivision, which typically features rows of single-family homes fronted by driveways, wide streets and large front yards.
"If this was easy to do," said Haythem Dawlett, one of Brandt's Crossing's master developers, "everyone would do it."
But despite the obstacles -- formed by half a century of zoning rules and cultural norms that favor subdivisions navigable mainly by car -- traditional neighborhoods have sprouted in such cities as Memphis, Tenn.; Gaithersburg, Md.; and Addison, near Dallas. There are a few in Central Texas, including Plum Creek in Kyle.
Elements of traditional neighborhoods can be found in new, upscale developments around Austin, such as Kinney Court: 60 houses south of Oltorf Street near Lamar Boulevard, averaging $300,000 each. Its small front yards, back alleys and narrow streets mimic the established environs of Hyde Park and Travis Heights.
But Kinney Court's developer, Bill Howell, had to fight city hall for three years, winning 27 variances and waivers from the zoning codes before breaking ground.
The traditional neighborhood ordinance was designed to cut through all that, but it applies only to large developments in East Austin, between 40 and 250 acres -- a larger and more expensive tract than most available in Central or West Austin.
"That's a lot of land to put together," said Harry Savio of the Texas Homebuilders' Association. "And when it takes a year and a half to develop a new, untested idea . . . well, lenders are very risk-averse."
Savio added, however, that he was excited to see at least one traditional project approved and another waiting in the wings. "It's an option many home buyers want."
Dawlett is counting on it. Though he and other developers tend to look dreamy when discussing traditional neighborhoods, they are also looking at a bottom line that they hope will pay off by building equivalently priced homes on smaller lots. Most of all, they are banking on the aesthetic appeal of living closer to neighbors, walking to the store and mixing with people of various ages and economic backgrounds.
"I think we'll start seeing an exodus out of the subdivisions," Dawlett said.
Meanwhile, city incentives, which include fee waivers and free sewer and water hookups, can help encourage traditional builders -- though those breaks are not officially a part of the ordinance.
"Our philosophy is that we're priming the pump," said George Adams of the city's planning department. "We're helping to create the market, and eventually, if it takes off, we'll let the market take its course."